The Five Pillars of My Disconcerting View of My American Christian Brethren Today
by drfuture2013
Some of my Christian friends think that I may be a little too critical these days of my fellow American Christians and paint with too broad of a brush, and they may think that I need to focus on my own spiritual inadequacies and shortcomings. They may well be right; I certainly criticize Christian behavior for which I myself have been guilty, and neglect important Christian work and ministry I should be about right now. It is easy to be a critic, and sit in the “seat of scoffers” as a judge and spectator, while others are “in the arena”.
Having said that, while I have been raised in the “bullseye” of the Bible Belt both culturally and geographically, and benefitted from its solid Christian worldview foundation and been blessed by its security, hope and sacrificial love from others toward me, I have been developing some type of angst or unsettled gut feeling about the culture itself, and how it expresses itself in some of its most “edgy” manifestations such as the “culture war”, political interactions and even Bible prophecy/foreign policy popular perspectives. This “symptom” has emerged ever since I began opening my mind to asking long-overdue questions and finally considering long-disregarded perspectives in the midst of my Future Quake radio show production era (which shows the blessing from even considering the “far out” topics such as Nephilim, UFOs and conspiracy topics then, if only as an essential mental exercise in free thinking). I need to reassure my fellow Christian leaders that I have not been shaken at all in regard to my committment to Jesus Christ or His teachings, or that of His apostles as expressed in the Bible; if anything, they have only become more solidified and in focus, which has ironically made them a central cause of my recent misgivings, particularly when I see so much now of my accepted “Christian culture” that does not line up with them. In a way I am catching up to younger Christians with far less experience as practicing Christians, and with a far smaller and more recent “cloud of witnesses” than I have been blessed to marinate in for over fifty years; in other words, my re-thinking is long overdue, and I have much to account for in this age of readily-available information and perspectives, if we only pursue them.
Future Quake listeners know that I began to ask some of these questions, often spurred by the guests of the week, news stories we discussed, the comments of my wise hosts Emmett and Tom Bionic, and even emails sent from listeners. I have also been blessed to be influenced by a circle of “merry men”, such as Adam Sayne at Conspirinormal, Tim and Andrew at Revelation Radio News, Chris White, other friends like “Paul from Texas” and particularly frequent guest (and mentor) Robert Heid of the Sycamore Three blog. One of my problems in this vein is to take all this disparate information and thoughts over the years and in the future and somehow “corral” it into some type of lucid and constructive framework and line of thinking; I read once that a measure of “genius” was “the ability to see relationships”, which can also be “cause and effect”, I suppose. The effort over the last several years of trying to write a coherent and organized book series The Holy War Chronicles – A Spiritual View of the War on Terror has helped somewhat in that regard, by necessity (in fact, I recommend the process to everyone), and in some way it touches on many if not all of the topics of my concerns, and disciplines me to express it logically and clearly (at least as a goal). I also will write brief (sometimes longer) position papers on related topics or new ways of considering them, and share them with my friends like those mentioned above – I am now going to try to express such ideas in this blog directly, to everyone, and hope they know that sometimes they are just “bits of undercooked potato” and temporary insanity that I will deny any association with later, and always just exercises in “thinking out loud”. However, in many respects they are still scattershot and not sculpted into a framework to identify important associations.
I am now going to take the first “kick at the can” in this vein, and now express an idea of such a framework I blurted out to my good friend Robert Heid when he dropped into town to visit yesterday, with a little more amplification I derived in the wee hours of last night. It is certainly inadequate and hopefully will at least jump-start a conversation on the topic – you can’t sculpt a masterpiece until you throw a hunk of clay up there, can you? I am attempting to categorize the basic categories of my beefs or disconcerting subjects into five “pillars” for the time being. I chose “five pillars” because I can view them as five in number, I thought it was clever, and it is a playful poke at my brethren in the “anti-sharia” crowd. Here’s my first crack at identifying the five broad “pillars” of my concerns (I also want to remind the reader that I know many Christians are not culpable for the attitudes I will reveal as being commonplace in the community in my perspective, including the far-sighted leaders in my own church and close friends of mine):
- Lack of Empathy: I see a widespread lack of empathy in many Christians today, particularly in their conspicuous public leadership as well as rank and file, which is sad since i see this as essential to being an effective disciple and witness for Christ. They are so easily led by their leaders to distrust anyone slightly different from them – even those who also profess Christ as well – and assign to them the worst (and usually unproven, or even unevidentiated) motives. They cannot even see the merits, much less exhibit the ability, of seeing the world and its events, and in particular the interpretation of the acts of Christians, through the eyes and perspectives of those raised in a different spiritual, geographic, ideological or ethnic culture. They are in such a rush to prove the “superiority” of their cultural views that they run roughshod over others. I don’t think most of them that I know have ever known was it felt like to be a minority in some sense – racially, ethnically or culturally – in a society with a hostile majority, and the vulnerability it produces, and sometimes radical actions in desperate reactions. They do not, and care not to know what it feels like “in another’s shoes”, unlike Jesus with the Samaritan Woman and other Gentiles, or Paul appealing from a Greek mindset on Mars Hill. Just a few minutes to intentionally try to view things from the “enemy”‘s view could accomplish much to calm physical or verbal hostilities, maintain a constructive dialogue and promote societal tranquility.
- No Ability of Self-Introspection: I know I have dwelt in this tent many times, as it stands strong in its assurance of its “rightness” and in the ability to point out the inadequacy in others, particularly camps with different views. It seems to not have the desire or ability to look inward at its own motives and blind spots, or myopia of what is going on. It does not consider the “dirty laundry” of its own history, be it the nation of the United States, the Christian community there or its leadership and actions, its religious denomination or political party, or even ethnic culture. It cannot see the “beam” of its own culture and “debts” it owes others that have not been paid, and for which restitution is probably the remedy to re-secure God’s blessings in our communities, but sadly being a recipe never considered by “proud” Americans. If we could only do this after learning what the West has done to the Middle East and its inhabitants over the last century or more, I am certain that it would greatly enhance peace and prosperity for all parties, regardless what the doom-and-gloom “Bible prophecy crowd” (I say lamentably as a life-long “prophecy buff”) and Christian Zionists of every stripe allege.
- A Disdain For Quality Research, Reading and Diverse Education: I suspect this problem can at least be traced back to the 1925 Monkey Scopes Trial, or even the Church and Galileo. In circumstances like the Scopes debacle, the Christian community, rather than revisiting what views for which they truly needed to “circle the wagons” around while being creative and open-minded in how to interact and converse with others, chose rather to adopt a “siege mentality” and become totally inward looking, and viewing with suspicion, fear and/or paranoia everyone on the outside, and any thoughts or views they might have. As a classically-trained scientist and seriously practicing Christian myself, I am often embarrassed to see the foolish and uninformed ways that Christian groups lash out at others – even those groups who have their own blind spots and mal intents as well at times, I admit. I did not recognize this so much until recently, but now I understand other Christian professors, professionals and “thinkers” who would cringe when the fundamentalists would pontificate on subjects for which they knew little to nothing legitimate about. It is easy to ridicule American Indians who were afraid that photographs would “steal their souls” or similar things in other cultures, yet not see it in one’s own. Other Christians have long criticized the Catholic Church for its persecution of Galileo for his assertion that the Earth circled the Sun, yet now it is making the rounds in other Christian circles that the earth is flat (I wonder if this is perpetuated by God to show how ludicrous some Christian communities have become, like Donald Trump and his embracement by much of the Religious Right). See how many Christian schools teach hard sciences and careers such as engineering and medicine – I assume most of these schools are content to consign members of these communities to Hell, and refuse to send bright Christians to interact with them. I routinely lament even close Christian friends who have no attention spans to read serious Christian, much less secular literature that espouses important ideas that exercise the mind. I find that many Christians I know do not want to be “bored” with reading any literature that considers a topic for more than a few pages, yet while they do not want to take the time to study an issue and its history from various perspectives, they are more than willing to invest time getting “educated” from talk radio and its Christian variants, as well as take time to frequently (and LOUDLY) express their draconian views against others based upon hearsay and unsubstantiated accusations, and reflect the same mindset at the ballot box. The Christian book stores of today are candy stores of intellectual and spiritual “bubble gum” by and large, with little regard for history, citations of others’ works and ideas from those outside their own myopic spheres. And they wonder why the world does not respect them any more! Hint, hint – the disrespect has nothing to do with Jesus or the BIble!
- No Concern For The Impact Their Pursuits Have On Others: Many Christians (mostly right wing, I must recognize) love to “talk tough” as “macho” Christians, particularly in political rallies, or when co-opting America’s military to bolster their own reputations and agendas. In reality, most of them are “cowards”, and would never speak so brashly and threateningly if they did not have a military funded by a budget roughly greater than the next ten nations in the world combined behind it; they would never dream of going to meet with Muslim leaders in Iran or elsewhere (even their own communities) to have constructive talks and “listening tours”, like good old Saint Francis. They use euphemisms like a “strong America” and “American leadership” to represent “gunboat diplomacy” to enforce the will of America (and in particular its corporations) on the other peoples of the world, without regard for their wishes or interests, as a true expression of “social Darwinism” while consigning its sole dangers to its perspective on the origins of our planet long ago. It likewise embraces social Darwinism in the economic realm in an “anything goes” environment where exploitation of those economically vulnerable are exploited routinely, with no mention by most of the Church, unlike the majority of God’s teaching through Jesus and the Old Testament prophets. They do not care if the poor do not get justice in the courts, the “thumbs are on the scales” in the marketplace against them, or how they suffer in any other way. They promote the use of gas-guzzling vehicles as a blatant expression of contempt for God’s creation, while the majority of the world cannot afford such scarce energy resources to refrigerate their food and medicines. To them, “sustainability” is a “four letter word”, and they promote feel-good patriotic wars that run up unpayable national debts on their children and grandchildren. How can American Christians say they “love their neighbor”? When will they start asking questions when they promote their various views – “Who pays as a result?”
- A Lack of Duty to Be Their Brother’s Keeper: Christians here in America, by and large, seem to take the perspective of Cain, and show ambivalence to the suffering and persecution of others, as long as it is not them. They don’t mind who is “left behind” (maybe the “rapture mentality” helps undergird this?). They have adopted the view from their 30 minute daily committment to the issues from Rush and Hannity during their commute and Fox News over dinner that the “poor” are all “lazy, dope and sex addicted, child creating, welfare abusing” burdens on society and humanity – even if many come from homes with no father or any positive role models, or unsafe schools. They don’t care if people in Iraq or Afghanistan are thrown into Gitmo without trials or evidence, or legal representation, or kept there for years because the government admits they have no evidence on them, the release of which would expose. They do not care about people of low mental aptitude who are exploited in FBI-generated “terror stings” as harmless people who never originally intended any harm, to be incarcerated next to some peaceful dudes who were found with some joints in their car. They are ambivalent or skeptical that blacks or others in low income neighborhoods are profiled and scared that they will be victims of police abuse even when they are minding their own business, nor seem to care that police forces have invested many millions of dollars in “less than lethal” technologies like Tasers, and then seem reticent to use them on those they decide they need to “take down”, like guys selling individual cigarettes. They do not care about the rights of those with whom they differ – Muslims, gays, atheists, etc. – and don’t care if they have Christian views shoved in their face, but if they in turn receive the most modest of push back, the Christian majority shrieks and yells “Christian persecution!” at the top of their lungs. Can they be surprised when no one is listening? Will they always leave up to the secularists, government or those in cults to minister to people in need, while they are busy “soul winning” door to door?
There you go – Mike’s “Five Pillars” of Discontent. Don’t be surprised to read many of my beefs in the months ahead to be related to one or more of these; in fact, I might just cite the pertinent “pillar” when commenting on them! I may decide to add a few more if I think of them later, but I sure hate to mess up the elegant “five pillars”, don’t you think?
P.S. For all the exhausted readers of this new blog – most of the entries will be nowhere NEAR this long (particularly the goofy ones!)
Interesting thoughts mike. In the back of my mind I have two categories that I use.
1. No reliance on the Holy Spirit. Evidenced as lack of prayer, empathy, loving other and in general the disciplines both external and internal of christian living.
2. Being infected with “American Narcissim” which I describe as an incessant need for more things all the time, even at the cost of others.
At any rate. I’m glad you are finally sharing this with the world. Good on you!
LikeLike
that is, two categories to describe what wrong with the christians in america.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Red Moon Rising – Hawaii and commented:
Good commentary here by Dr. Future. Please read and reflect…
LikeLike
Dr. Future it’salways great to get your perspective on things. Your show really helped open me up to different ways of thinking and challengd me at times. Looking forward to reading not only this blog but your upcoming books as wel. Maybe we’ll eve get a small taste of your opus ; )
LikeLike
I’d like to address number 1: Lack of Empathy.
<>
I would have agreed with this until I witnessed what happened to Richard Mourdock, a conservative Christian Senate candidate in my home state (the Hoosier state) when he did nothing more than confess the Christian teaching that all life, even life conceived in rape, is a gift from God and what God intended to happen. This man did nothing more than confess Christian faith, and he was hounded out of the public square and respectable company, including by his fellow Republicans and conservatives. Ann Coulter still makes snarky remarks about him.
Do you think Mr. Mourdock knows what it feels like to be a minority? With a hostile majority?
Second incident I thought of….the pizza joint (also in the Hoosier state) which declared that they would not cater a gay wedding. They went on to receive death threats. They were hounded on social media. They were forced to close. Do you think they know what it feels like to be a minority? With a hostile majority?
You could ask the men and women who counsel outside of abortion clinics whether they know what it’s like to be a minority with a hostile majority. Or the county clerks in Kentucky who won’t issue same sex mirage licenses.
In other words, the hostility doesn’t seem nearly as one sided as you suppose. There are a lot of Americans who are actively hostile to Christian faith. It isn’t because Christians are mean, or Christians started a culture war. It’s because Christian faith offends them and they hate God. Such were some of us.
LikeLike
I guess my response to your points (and thank you for making them) is that in those cases where Christians are truly persecuted – and not those where they are somewhat complicit – that its concern should be less so for us than rather God’s concern, in terms of His purposes for His children to suffer, and His watchcare over them. I think we should rather be concerned with our mission to be our “brother’s keeper” and the “good Samaritan” as a “neighbor” to others who are vulnerable.
I also think the desire to protect those of one’s own tribe – even amongst us Christians – is more instinctual, natural, and maybe even carnal. I suspect that the “Gentiles” and pagans also bear this instinct for their own – maybe even Satanists. I feel that we Christians are called to a “higher calling” of selflessness, if our gospel and Holy Spirit empowerment truly has something advanced and superior to offer the rest of the world.
LikeLike
Sorry-don’t mean to sound critical, but I can’t get past your headline: do you mean “disconcerting”? (I don’t think “disconcerning” is a real word.)
LikeLike
Oops! Guess I better edit! Better limit my writing in the wee hours!
LikeLike
Don’t be surprised at persecution!
LikeLike
I feel that the lack of empathy in the church today is a symptom of the influence of conservative political views on Christian thought. Christians concerned about the abortion and other morality issues have allowed themselves to be tied to the Republican Party. Rather than influencing the party with concerns about poverty, humanity’s God-given responsibility to care for the environment, and other issues, Christians have not been aware that they have been manipulated into believing the Republican political ideology is scripturally based. I am not saying that all Republican ideas are wrong and the Democratic party’s ideas are right; just that a political platform is not inspired by God.
Self-introspection is difficult if everything one says is said with over-confidence and backed up with scripture. In my last few weeks while attending seminary, a pastor asked me if my faith in the reliability of the Bible was weaken by the teaching of the professors. I responded that on the contrary, it was strengthened. My faith in interpretation of the bible was greatly weakened. I do feel that some use wishful thinking when interpreting the Bible, trying not to deal with passages that are not convenient or socially popular. That though does not justify unthinking acceptance of commonly held interpretations.
I have seen those that see academics as the enemy of Christianity, but I generally do not see this as an aspect that permeates all of Christianity. I have seen certain pretexts from big business interest being taught as biblical reasons to not believe in global warming. Christians should try the acertain the validity of all information that they receive, regardless of the source. The failure to do this though, is not solely a Christian problem.
I do not feel that Christians if informed would be as uncaring they appear to be. Christians that brought the plight of the Sudanese to the attention of the world, but as the Sudanese did not have a resource which could be plundered only limited action was taken. Christians and other that become more aware of the situations in other countries will be in a better place to access and influence the actions of their governments. I do not feel that American’s (not just Christians) feel that every that everything that their country does is right, but that they are given a propagandized view of the world and based on what they see, their country is doing is right.
I agree that the apparent lack of concern about others disturbing, but I think that the lack of creativity in addressing poverty and social problems has contributed to this problem. There are those with good motives see the harm that can be caused to individuals and society, by removing rewards for work and wise behavior, and see waste in any social program. This type of thinking doesn’t take Into a account a child that is suffering right now that can’t wait for his parents to get it together. There are those that in good faith want to improve the outcomes by blinding throwing resources at problems. Resources are given to groups that do not have the ability or knowhow to deal with issues. We see social issues as binary problems, without being creative enough to develop new solutions that don’t already exist.
I think that Christians feel that they are being their brother’s keeper by trying to preserve their understanding of marriage. I think that a number of Christians are having to consider a world that they have never had to consider. US laws are filled with tools to influence individuals to have “good” behavior; e.g. tax credits, subsidized interest rates on home loans, and prohibitions against marrying close relatives. These are all things that have been agreed to by society. Society is changing. Those agreements have and will change over time. Some for the good, some for the better. I do not believe that all ideas are equal, but that ideas are worth equal consideration. I believe that Christians should encourage positive social agreements in a respectful and educated way; seeking to improve those agreements without blind commitment to existing agreements out of comfort. Christians should be wise and realize that any tool they use to control behavior will inevitably be used to control their behavior. There are ways to disagree with someone without disrespecting them. There are ways to recognize that someone has problems and still love them; even more reason to love them.
This is an interesting read showing that some of the Christian problems noted are not Christian problems but American problems.
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/09/the-coddling-of-the-american-mind/399356/
LikeLike
I completely agree with your assessment and list of points of complaint Mike. It is definitely a list for purposes of self improvement, and also for external critical assessment.
As an Australian, I can say that we have no equivalent to the Bible belt (to my dismay in fact) – a lack of history concerning pilgrims fleeing the High Church – but as you say, there are benefits and also pitfalls in the way in which Christian zeal is expressed. The Zealots at the time of Christ learned the hard way, so perhaps this is just prophecy unfolding on the Church in repetition. It can only be a purifying process in a macro way, and as we have been told, it is necessary that those practicing hypocrisy are brought to their knees.
In Australia our ‘conservative’ leaders and especially political parties who place the name ‘Christian’ into their party name, are a good example some times as to how the name of Christ is used contrary to his intentions. Germany is a great example in light of the Greek crisis: ‘Christian’ Democratic parties on the European Continent have proven themselves to be some of the worst exploiters of the good name of Jesus Christ. This is not just a problem for the people of the United States: unfortunately it is worldwide!
God bless.
LikeLike
Dr. Future thanks for writing this. I agree, and as a response I would like to encourage everyone to pray for two types of people. Pray for the individuals of the Body of Christ that Mike has outlined in these pillars (which is all of us at times if we are being honest). Pray for those trapped in the left-right paradigm of hate. Pray that they/we might be brought to awareness of our lack of understanding. But in addition, pray for those in positions of leadership who might be pressured, coerced, or even blackmailed into compromising their principles, we don’t know what it’s like to be in their shoes. But in addition to this, pray for those doing the blackmailing! Pray for those who fan the flames of hate and divide in our world, pray that they might be lead to the truth and love of Jesus. Pray that they might have a monumental spiritual upheaval like the Apostle Paul and repent. We have got to stop seeing ideological/theological opponents as adversaries, leave that to God, we need to see them as lost sheep, and weep over any and all that have not yet come home.
LikeLike
Thanks for the wise words, brother!
LikeLike
Dr. Mike, every time I start talking about this everyone just totally tunes out and tells me to take it to God. I AM a minority. Everything about my life screams that notion. But others form of empathy towards me is to pass me off to God every time. I have NO friends. I couldn’t get a date with another girl if my life depended on it. I have been a “genius” since I was a child but because of my mothers incompetence, I never got sent to the proper schools that I required (Mom is a emotional control freak feminist who thinks she’s a Christian because she hangs crosses up). I am a white guy who grew up in the projects. I have no real friends I can act with socially. I was once a criminal who broke the law constantly. And now I am a Christian and ever since that happened, I have had very few people to interact with outside of the internet. I was once discipled by Chris White over emails but now he wont respond to anything I send him. The only thing I can draw from all of this is God wants me to have nothing but hatred for these people. I get off dropping truth bombs on them which always ruffles their feathers). Are there really no empathetic people willing to go out of their way for brethren that are losing their sanity? I really am alone and I am tired of “going to God” for everything. God isn’t answering my prayers and my heart is dying. Recently, I have been forced to move back into my mothers home which comes with its own trials and tribulations. I don’t know what to do and I am tired of this. Something has to give. I have NO dignity. I don’t drink anymore. I don’t smoke anymore. I don’t commit sexual sin anymore. I don’t play video games anymore. I don’t watch TV anymore. I’ve read my Bible cover to cover and I can arrive at the truth logically. I work on my computer running Linux. I have NO motivation. I’m beginning to have the shakes and I am starting to stutter in my voice. I scream at God to give me an answer why I am just suffering all the time. I’m sorry to unload on you like this but I just don’t care about anything anymore. I just tell my story and hope someone cares.
In my heart I want America to burn, because somehow it feels like justice to me.
LikeLike
Brother Matt,
I am so sorry this world is troubling you so; I can understand in many ways. I have had long periods of loneliness and isolation myself, when I was a young man, also while I was trying to faithfully serve the Lord. I am not sure what I can offer to address your frustration and depression (because other people will always disappoint you eventually), but I offer a few suggestions that may seem lame to you:
1. Take a break from finding a deep truth from God, and rather focus your energies for a spell on developing any new skills, particularly those that can help in better job opportunities. We all go through spells where God is a little quiet, and its okay to focus on “rendering to Caesar” for a while in things that help our fortunes and our confidence and self-respect until He has something new to say to you.
2. When I get really wound up, I find some long walks somehow help unwind the tension that circumstances like you describe build up in me, and sometimes triggers new thoughts that helps in certain areas of my life.
3. Although none of them will be interested in the things you and I are, find the best local church you can find, and start doing some things socially and in joint service with others (worry about the fine points of doctrine later), even if it is not with people your age right now. We need to interact with people, particularly in doing good things and relaxing, or we all get crazy.
4. Don’t put pressure on yourself to understand everything, or figure it out – none of us have either, but we enjoy deliberating together, and the journey.
5. I have said before that there are plenty of people who want to hear our concerns, and listen – they are sitting in nursing homes and hospitals. They will remember what you asked them to pray for, and they will see you as their “hero” when you show up as their only contact with the outside world. I have gone in every time a little depressed, and came out feeling better. People like that can be your most trusted and loyal friends.
If I think of some more ideas, I’ll provide them. Noen of them are magical, and maybe a little lame, but I did not mention God or anything in Christian platitudes. I know you are really hurting.
LikeLike
Oh Dr. Mike!
God bless you! You are SO unlike everyone else out here!!!!!
Thank you! I am SOOOOO going to take your advice to heart.
I am following your works intensively and am looking forward to the books.
THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU!!!!!!!!!!!
LikeLike